An Email Addressing the Practical Use of Dynamic Symmetry in Art
"I read your article on the basics of composition and the use of Dynamic Symmetry, but I am currently struggling to believe it's a realistic tool used in real life painting and drawing since it's rigid and feels more like an analytical tool. So I would like to inquire if you personally know of any painters that use the Dynamic Symmetry grid for painting and composition.
Because I have followed the artist (named removed) work for some time, which you used as an example on your website, I asked them if they used this grid before creating the painting, and they said "no" and that it just happened to fall on this Dynamic Symmetry grid. Thus, to me, it reinforces my thinking that it can be used as an analytical tool but not as a useful tool to paint in real life situation and compose your painting."
There are many artists that won't speak openly about how they design their art. Much like the magician that won't reveal how they perform their illusions (the magician’s oath and code of ethics), artists have always carefully guarded the most important secret when it comes to creating masterful work; that being composition. This philosophy is known as the "painter's secret geometry." And because very few people have the skills to be able to decode design, it's not difficult for the artist to maintain the "illusion" that producing great art is intuitive and spontaneous.
While it does take time, skills, and patience to learn how to analyze art, a masterpiece is always measurable. And despite the fact that many artists aren't forthright about their use of Dynamic Symmetry or the armature of the rectangle, as discussed in Charles Bouleau's book "The Painter's Secret Geometry," that is in no way a reliable indicator that they haven't applied it to their designs. In fact, in all the years I have been analyzing artworks, I haven't found one example of any master artist who didn't employ at least some elements of the golden section in their compositions.
Furthermore, Dynamic Symmetry is not impractical or rigid and applying a proper system of design is imperative for creating a successful work of art. In today's culture, many artists mistakenly use the word "rigid" when they really mean structure. However, a masterpiece must always have a well-composed design. Otherwise, the artwork will appear chaotic and ultimately fail in its attempt to affect the viewer emotionally.
Unfortunately, because of the 20th Century Modern Art movement in America, many artists have been falsely led to believe any technical training inhibits creativity. This nonsensical "teach by not teaching" ideology has left the art world and most modern art students in a constant state of emotional struggle and self-doubt. Most importantly, without design, art cannot exist. So, not only is Dynamic Symmetry a realistic tool, it's a necessary tool if an artist or photographer ever expects to create work that is worthy of being called "art."
To download a free PDF copy of "The Art of Composition: A Dynamic Symmetry User's Guide for the Modern Artist," click here.
Painting below by Anna Rose Bain designed using the armature of the 1.5 rectangle.